Did you know that a well-built deck can boost your home’s value by up to 10%? For homeowners in Pennsylvania looking to transform their backyards, choosing the right wood decking material is the first step toward creating an outdoor oasis. Whether you’re sipping coffee on a crisp morning or hosting a summer barbecue, your deck sets the stage. But here’s the big question: cedar vs. redwood? Both are stunning options, and with help from skilled local deck builders, you can make a choice that fits your budget, style, and maintenance preferences. In this guide, we’ll break down the differences, weigh the pros and cons, and help you decide which wood is worth the investment for your next deck installation.
What Makes Cedar and Redwood Stand Out?
Cedar and redwood aren’t your average lumberyard finds. These premium woods bring natural beauty and durability to any outdoor deck builder project. They’ve been favorites for decades, thanks to their resistance to rot, insects, and weathering—perfect for Pennsylvania’s mix of humid summers and snowy winters. But while they share some traits, their differences could sway your decision. Let’s dive into what sets them apart.
Cedar: The Lightweight Contender
Cedar, often Western Red Cedar, is known for its warm, golden hues that deepen over time. It’s lighter than most hardwoods, making it easier for crews to handle during the deck setup process. Plus, it’s packed with natural oils that fend off bugs and decay—a big win for anyone tired of replacing warped boards. Learn more about cedar’s natural benefits from the experts.
- Cost: Typically ranges from $4 to $8 per square foot.
- Look: Rich tones with tight, consistent grain patterns.
- Weight: Lighter, around 23 pounds per cubic foot.
Homeowners in Pennsylvania love cedar for its affordability and low upkeep. A quick stain every couple of years keeps it looking fresh, and its natural scent? That’s just a bonus.
Redwood: The Luxury Pick
Redwood, sourced mainly from California, screams elegance with its deep reddish-brown color. It’s denser and tougher than cedar, offering a premium feel underfoot. Like cedar, it has natural preservatives, but its tighter grain gives it an edge in longevity—some redwood decks last 20+ years with minimal fuss. Check out redwood’s premium edge for a deeper dive.
- Cost: Higher, usually $6 to $12 per square foot.
- Look: Bold, striking red tones that age gracefully.
- Weight: Heavier, about 26 pounds per cubic foot.
Redwood’s upscale vibe makes it a go-to for those wanting a standout deck. It’s a favorite among our deck-building crew for clients aiming to impress.
Comparing the Two: A Side-by-Side Breakdown
Still torn? Let’s put cedar and redwood head-to-head with a clear comparison. This table highlights key factors Pennsylvania homeowners should consider before calling an outdoor deck builder.
| Feature | Cedar | Redwood |
| Price per Sq. Ft. | $4–$8 | $6–$12 |
| Durability | Good (15–20 years) | Excellent (20–30 years) |
| Maintenance | Stain every 2–3 years | Stain every 3–5 years |
| Color | Golden to reddish-brown | Deep red to dark brown |
| Weight | Lighter (23 lbs/cu. ft.) | Heavier (26 lbs/cu. ft.) |
| Eco-Friendliness | Sustainably sourced often | Limited supply, less sustainable |
Cedar’s lower cost and solid lifespan make it a practical pick. Redwood, though pricier, delivers unmatched durability and a luxe aesthetic. Your choice might hinge on how long you plan to stay in your home—or how much you’re willing to spend upfront.
Pros and Cons: What’s the Catch?
No material is perfect, right? Here’s a closer look at what you’re signing up for with each.
Cedar Pros and Cons
- Pros:
- Budget-friendly for quality wood.
- Easy to work with during deck installation.
- Naturally resists insects and rot.
- Cons:
- Softer than redwood, so it dents more easily.
- Fades faster without regular staining.
A friend of mine built a cedar deck in Bucks County a few years back. He swears by its cozy vibe, but he’s out there with a brush every other spring to keep it sharp.
Redwood Pros and Cons
- Pros:
- Tougher and longer-lasting.
- Stunning color that holds up over time.
- Less frequent maintenance.
- Cons:
- Higher initial cost.
- Heavier, which can bump up labor fees.
Redwood’s heft and price tag might give you pause, but its “set it and forget it” appeal is hard to beat. One local outdoor deck builder told me it’s their top request for high-end projects.
Which Is Better for Pennsylvania Weather?
Let’s talk climate. Pennsylvania throws everything at your deck—humid summers, freezing winters, and plenty of rain. Both cedar and redwood handle moisture well, but redwood’s denser structure gives it a slight edge against cracking in cold snaps. Cedar, though, dries out faster after a downpour, which is handy if you’re dodging mold in shadier yards. The wood durability science backs this up with hard data.
For snowy months, a good sealant is key no matter which you pick. Wood deck builders often recommend a high-quality penetrating oil to lock out water and UV rays. I’ve seen cedar decks in Montgomery County hold up beautifully with this trick, even after brutal winters.
Cost vs. Value: Where’s the Payoff?
Your wallet’s probably whispering at this point. Cedar’s lower price makes it tempting, especially if you’re watching pennies. A 200-square-foot cedar deck might run you $800–$1,600 in materials, while redwood could hit $1,200–$2,400. Labor costs for deck-building costs vary, but expect $15–$35 per square foot depending on complexity.
Long-term, redwood’s durability might save you on repairs or replacements. According to the National Association of Realtors, a deck can recoup 70–80% of its cost when you sell. So, if redwood lasts a decade longer, that’s more value in your pocket. Cedar’s no slouch either—it’s just a shorter-term bet.
Maintenance Made Simple
Worried about upkeep? Both woods are low-maintenance compared to pressure-treated pine, but they’re not hands-off. Cedar needs a stain or sealant every 2–3 years to fight fading. Redwood can stretch to 3–5 years, thanks to its richer oils. Skip this step, and you’ll get that weathered gray look—cool if you’re into it, costly if you’re not.
Pro tip: Sweep off leaves and hose it down quarterly. Pennsylvania’s pollen and snow can build up fast, and a little TLC keeps your deck pristine. Ask your wood deck builders for a finish that matches your vibe—clear for natural tones or tinted for extra pop.
Sustainability: Green Living Matters
Eco-conscious? Cedar’s often harvested sustainably in North America, with replanting programs keeping supplies steady. Redwood’s trickier—its old-growth forests are dwindling, and newer plantations can’t fully meet demand. If green building’s your thing, cedar might feel like the guilt-free pick.
Making Your Choice
So, cedar or redwood? If you want affordability and charm without heavy upkeep, cedar’s your match. Craving a showstopper that lasts decades? Redwood’s worth the splurge. Either way, teaming up with a skilled outdoor deck builder ensures your investment shines. At the Bucks Mont Decks team, we’ve seen both woods transform Pennsylvania backyards into retreats—your dream deck’s just a get a free quote away. Need more deck design inspiration? We’ve got you covered.
What’s your take? Drop a comment below with your pick, or share this with a friend weighing their options. Ready to get started? Reach out to local wood deck builders and turn your backyard vision into reality!
